Hardball's teams and executives have won numerous awards including:
- No. 1 Overall Minor League Ballpark Experience (Stadium Journey, 2015)
- Executive of the Year (Midwest League, 2015)
- Sports Turf Manager/Grounds Crew of the Year (Midwest League, 2015)
- Minor League Baseball's John Henry Moss Community Service Award Nominee (Midwest League, 2015)
- Best Theme Night Finalist (Minor League Baseball, 2015)
- Team of the Year (Ballpark Digest, 2014)
- No. 1 Overall Minor League Ballpark Experience (Stadium Journey, 2014)
- No. 10 Sports Venue Experience in the U.S. and Canada (Stadium Journey, 2014)
- Best New Food Item (Ballpark Digest, 2014)
- Single-A Sports Turf Manager of the Year (Minor League Baseball/Sports Turf Managers Association, 2014)
- Rawlings Woman Executive of the Year (Midwest League, 2014)
- Sports Turf Manager/Grounds Crew of the Year (Midwest League, 2014)
- Larry McPhail Award, Best Marketing and Promotions (Midwest League, 2013)
- Single-A Sports Turf Manager of the Year (Minor League Baseball/Sports Turf Managers Association, 2013)
- Sports Turf Manager/Grounds Crew of the Year (Midwest League, 2013)
- Hoosier Hospitality Award Winner (Indiana Office of Tourism Development, 2012)
- Golden Bobblehead Award Nominee, Best Non-Gameday Event (Minor League Baseball, 2012)
- Grounds Crew of The Year (Midwest League, 2012)
- Golden Bobblehead Award Winner, Best Overall Promotion (Minor League Baseball, 2011)
- Golden Bobblehead Award Winner, Best Theme Night (Minor League Baseball, 2011)
- Bob Freitas "Organization of the Year" Award (Baseball America, 2011)
- Best Overall Minor League Ballpark Experience (Stadium Journey, 2011)
- Larry McPhail Award, Best Marketing and Promotions (Midwest League, 2011)
- Rawlings Woman Executive of the Year Award (Midwest League, 2011)
- Grounds Crew of The Year (Midwest League, 2011)
- Field of The Year (Midwest League, 2011)
- John H. Johnson Award, Best Run Franchise (Midwest League, 2010)
- Recognized as one of 12 "Great Ballparks of America" (Baseball America, 2010)
- Larry McPhail Award, Best Marketing and Promotions (Midwest League, 2010)
- Executive of the Year Award (South Atlantic League, 2010)
- Field of The Year (Midwest League, 2010)
- Grounds Crew of The Year (Midwest League, 2010)
- Minor League Baseball Team of the Year (MiLB.com, 2009)
- Organization of the Year (Ballpark Digest, 2009)
- Single-A Team of the Year (Baseball America, 2009)
- John H. Johnson Award, Best Run Franchise (Midwest League, 2009)
- Best Land Use (Indiana Department of Environmental Management, 2009)
- International Downtown Association Award of Distinction (2009)
- Large Business of the Year (Fort Wayne Chamber of Commerce, 2009)
- Best Marketing Campaign (Ballpark Digest, 2009)
- Best New Logo (MiLB.com, 2009)
- Logo of the Year (Ballpark Digest, 2009)
- Executive of the Year Award (Midwest League, 2009)
- Executive of the Year Award (Carolina League, 2006)